| Platinum | Piece of Cake Lafayette |
| Gold | Crumbl Cookies - River Marketplace |
| Silver | Carolines Cookies |
| Bronze | Nothing Bundt Cakes Lafayette |
| Top Pick | Great American Cookies |
| Top Pick | Great Harvest Bread Company |
| Top Pick | Poupart Bakery |
| Top Pick | She Bakes & More LLC |
| Top Pick | The Cookie Door |